Car Comparisons' Car Of The Year 2005 - Nominations (LAST DAY!!!)

Read this before posting:

Well its December and 2005 it’s coming to an end. Therefore it’s our duty to choose the car which defined the last 12 months of our lives.

This is the nominations thread. You will choose 3 cars and rate them:

1st place will receive 3 points
2nd place will receive 2 points
3rd place will receive 1 point


After about two weeks this thread will be closed and the moderating team will tally up the points. The top 10 rated cars will go on a poll where they will stay till the end of the year. On the first of January one car will have the honor of being acclaimed as Car Comparison's Car Of The Year.

Only cars available on the market during 2005 may apply. (cars marketed by manufacturers as "2006 models" are also eligible)

Feel free to discuss and debate your choices, in a civilized manner of course. But do make sure to post your nominations clearly (use of bolds is suggested) otherwise there is a chance we might miss them during the final tally. Also please type in the full name and model of the car nominated.

"Tuner" cars are not eligible unless considered by a national government as a standalone car such as in the case of Ruf (licensed as a car manufacturer by the German government) whose cars stop being officially Porche after he is done with them.

Specify the exact model of the car!!! (eg. Mustang GT; Mustang V6 etc...). If you think of an older model specify otherwise the latest model will be assumed.

Thank You:)

1. Ferrari F430 - 3pts
2. Aston Martin V8 Vantage - 2pts
3. BMW M5 - 1pts

I chose as #1 the ferrari since its a tecnological masterpice while offering all of the red ferrari passion we came to expect, what it lost in elegance to the 360 it more than made up in performance.

The baby aston comes at #2 since its an "afordable" model almost as good looking as the DB9 and it comes with a manual!!!

The teutonic computer on wheels comes at #3 since it offers us 500 hp worth of supercar performance in a sensible sedan (dads of the world rejoice - well at least the rich dads;))

1. BMW M5 (E60) - 3pts
2. Pagani Zonda F - 2pts
3. Ferrari F430 - 1 pt

The new M5 is the daddy of all supersaloons. 500bhp, 200mph. Nuff said.
The Zonda F improves on the already stunning C12S and is a staggering achievement for such a new car manufacturer.
Finally, while im not a huge fan of its looks, the F430 is simply an animal and deserves a place in the top 3.

1) BMW M5 3pts
2) Audi RS4 2pts
3) Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution 1pt

chose S4 over the M3 cuz the redesigned smaller 4.2L V8 delivers 414bhp, and 06 Mitsu Evo over the 06 STi (close call with this rivalry, but i'm siding with Evo this time). Sorry, i don't have enough know-all on cars in class with Pagani, Ferrari, and Lambo's to chose one there.

i like em all but if i had to rate em....



Ferrari F430-(3 pts.)
BMW M5-(2 pts.)
WRX Impreza STi-(1 pts.)

1. Ferrari F430 - 3pts
2. Vett z06 - 2pts
3. Aston Martin V8 Vantage -1pt

1. Ferrari F430 - 3pts
2. Lancer Evo IX MR - 2 pts
3. Corvette Z06 - 1 pt

1. Chevrolet Corvette Z06
2. BMW M5
3. Pontiac Solstice

The Corvette Z06 is ultimately the best bang for you buck sports car on the market today. It competes with the supercars as a very un-supercar price....my only question is that does this car actually count as a 2005 COTY?

100hp/L is always very tough to accomplish...but to be able to do it out of 5L with adequate torque and high revs is absolutely astounding

IMO the solstice is an amazing little roadster...The thing absolutely flies when you want it to, but can be civil and calm on your less energetic days...I have driven it, and I am a believer!

OK here are my common guy picks...

Mustang GT - 3PT
Corvette C6- 2PT
Colorado - 1PT

Ferrari's are great but I can't touch them with my buying power... I like what Ford did with the new Mustang as it looks great with a slight retro style to it, the new Corvette just plain smokes anything under $60K, and I know its a truck but the new Chevy Colorado pickup five cylinder is just plain innovative.....

BMW M5 E60 = 3 points

Simply because its the best compromise between sport and comfort.

Buggati Veyron = 2 points

Well, do it get more insame than with this machinery. 1001 BHP and over 400 kmp/H. THis car will sure set the benchmark for a long time.

Ferrari 430 = 1 point

The best driving machine today. Everything is made to perfection with this fine piece of engineering. What an engine !!

OK here are my common guy picks...

Mustang GT - 3PT
Corvette C6- 2PT
Colorado - 1PT

Please type the full name of the car, so Ford Mustang GT, Chevrolet Colorado. It makes it easier for us to add everything up at the end.


2. Vett - 2pts
C6? Z06?

1. Chevrolet Corvette Z06.
2. Cadillac CTS-V
3. Saturn Sky

1. Bugatti Veyron (3 points) Bugatti Picture (http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.seriouswheels.com/pics-abc/Bugatti-Veyron-Study-2-Red-Front-Angle-1600x1200.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.seriouswheels.com/abc/Bugatti-EB-16-4-Veyron-Study-II-Red-Front-Angle-1600x1200.htm&h=1200&w=1600&sz=182&tbnid=INBtxQDbD74J:&tbnh=112&tbnw=150&hl=en&start=11&prev=/images%3Fq%3DBugatti%2BVeyron%26svnum%3D10%26hl%3D en%26lr%3D)
2. Mosler MT900S (2 points) Mosler Picture (http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.autofotos.com/Mosler%2520MT900S%2520Left%2520Beauty.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.autofotos.com/mosler_mt900s.htm&h=379&w=600&sz=53&tbnid=iz8IJNFzooEJ:&tbnh=84&tbnw=133&hl=en&start=2&prev=/images%3Fq%3DMosler%26svnum%3D10%26hl%3Den%26lr%3D )
3. BMW M5 (1 points) BMW Picture (http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.fantasycars.com/sedans/bmw/bmwm51.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.fantasycars.com/sedans/html/m5.html&h=480&w=642&sz=57&tbnid=aMUBaf5EZ78J:&tbnh=100&tbnw=135&hl=en&start=9&prev=/images%3Fq%3DBMW%2BM5%26svnum%3D10%26hl%3Den%26lr% 3D)

How can't you just fall in love with the new Bugatti. The things a masterpiece. It never hurts to go 252mph straight from the factory!
I really love the fact that the Mosler has that race car look straight from the factory yet is still street legal. Also, its nice its got the balls to hold its own.
And of course the M5. I've loved this car since I first seen it. It doesn't hurt that its actually got a reasonable price as well!!

Please type the full name of the car, so Ford Mustang GT, Chevrolet Colorado. It makes it easier for us to add everything up at the end.



C6? Z06?


...you better add that in you instructions then, otherwise you'll be posting his same reminder a lot I fear....

I will stick to models sold in the US.

1: FORD GT

"Bang for the Buck?" this will compete with anything twice its price

2: CHEVROLET COBALT SS SUPERCHARGED

I have driven one. filthy quick and and incredible handling. Any more sporty and it will eclipse the Vette

3: CHRYSLER 300C SRT-8

Luxury and 425bhp and 420 torque for the common mans price. Mopar flexes some Hemi Muscle.

SRT-4 and Charger SRT-8 would have made the list, but both have a few too many doors for what they are...

1. Ferrari F430 (3 points)
2. Bmw M5 (2 points)
3. Zonda F (1 point )

Ferrari simple yet stylish , Refine , Performance of a truely Fine tuned car , Great soundtrack ! Class of its own

Bmw M5 Work of art in terms of handling for a saloon , Powerful yet great as a cruiser , has a soundtrack close to a F430. Bad point which made me put it into 2nd place was the amount of electronics setting u have to set b4 u can get it going lol.

Zonda F Mr Pagani's opinion of the best Zonda he built , naming it the F , brutal power from the merc 7.3 lit v 12 engine. A nutter supercar. Downside... The looks hasnt changed much which made me put it in 3 place

1) BMW E60 M5

If you were doubting before, BMW truly has made the Ultimate Driving Machine. $80,000, 500bhp, 7sp SMG, 4 doors, and a BMW Interior. To me, this car is symbolic of BMW's rise to the best selling premium make.

2) Ferrari F430

If I could afford one, I wouldn't hesitate to buy one. Best Ferrari yet. They sound absolutely amazing. I'll take one in Ferrari red, with an F1 transmission (sry guys).

3) BMW E90 3-Series

What Dinan put two BMW's on his list? This was actually a tough one. The C6 Z06 is a very good car as well, as is the Porsche Cayman, but my unlimited love for the 3-series pulled through. Its the Automobile Magazine car of the year, and its everything you'd expect from the 3-series. Great handling, great feel, good power. It also beat out the more powerful IS350 and G35 in C&D.

1. Chevrolet Corvette Z06
2. Ford GT
3. Chevrolet Cobalt SS/SC

1+2 to me where tied. I like both cars equally. I had to go with the cobalt because when it come to 4cyl. vehicles i believe its top of its class.

1. Chevy Corvette Z06 - 3 points
2. Dodge Charger SRT-8 - 2 points
3. BMW M5 - 1 point

Dodge Charger SRT-8 = 3pts
Pontiac Grand Prix GXP = 2pts
Chevrolet Corvette Z06 = 1pt

BMW M5 - 3PTS

BMW M3 - 2PTS

Infiniti G35 - 1 PT

Was going to put the F430 somewhere in there, but then compared it's styling again to the, now old, 360...

Lamborghini Murcielago Convertible: 3pts

It's everything I love about exotics, all wrapped up in a gorgeous package, minus the roof.

Dodge Viper SRT10 Coupe: 2pts

The latest generation of one of the most beastly, uncompromising streetcars ever. (Plus I got to drive the droptop version last spring, so I can really appreciate the kind of power this car has.)

Mazda MX-5: 1pt

Latest generation of the pure, affordable, reliable, convertible sportscar. (This one kinda ties with the Pontiac Solstice, but I use to drive a Miata, so they will forever hold a special place in my heart.)



Ecordeddie, I agree with you about the Chevy Colorado. I drive one now, and I love it. The five-cylinder is so much more than I expected, and the truck is way more refined and ergonomic than I figured it would be.

#1-Bentley Conti GT (Luxo-Rocket to the stars)
#2-BMW M5 (RS/AMG/SRT/V-Series eater!)
#3-Infiniti M45 (Most Improved Of Year)

Not yet available, but worthy of mention, the Cadillac STS-V. Glad that GM decided to hand-build major components; like intercooled 4.4 liter Roots-type supercharged V8s producing 469HP/439TQ. Good job, guys. Now take the 6L80 TAPShift rear-drive 6-speed from the Vette and STS-V and put it in a midsize (like a new Monte) with the 303HP 5.3 liter LS4 V8......and BANG!!!! YOUR SALES COME BACK!!!!!!

Regarding the user who suggested the Cobalt, the WRX or SRT-4 ACR are much more powerful, better overall choices, IMO.


My votes:
1 - Chevrolet Corvette Z06
2 - Mercedes CLS
3 - Mazda RX-8


The Vette is a great value, cannot be beaten by any street legal car (excl. cars like the Radical which i'd hardly consider a real car due to its impracticality) under, like 150K USD.

The CLS has a beautiful design and as Brabus showed, it can have power. They reached like 800 or 900 lbs of torque at 2400 RPMs. And about 750 hp.

I love the design of the RSX, the Rotary is a very intriguing design, the freestyle 4 doors are cool, and its handling and braking are amazing.

1. BMW M5
2. Bugatti Veyron
3. Ferrari F430

1) 2006 Chevrolet Corvette C6 Z06 - 3 pts
2) 2006 Ford GT - 2 pts
3) 2006 Cadillac XLR-V - 1 pt

1.chevrolet corvette Z06- 3 points
2.dodge charger srt-8- 2 points
3.ford mustang gt-1 point

1. Ferrari F-430 - 3 points (loved the F-360, love this one even more)
2. Infiniti M45 - 2 points (watch out BMW, Infiniti is catching up quickly)
3. BMW M5 - 1 point (the M-series BMWs have always been one of my dream cars, and this is no exception)

Evo easly takes first, the proformance to price ratio says it all
Z06 takes second, great proformance, awsome styling, runs neck and neck with cars that cost four times as much.
WRX STi Takes third, it is not quite on par with the EVO for balls to the wall proformance but very close, i would have put it second but I don't like the bubble look. I prefer the look of the late 90s models.

BMW M5 (3 pt.)

Bugatti Veyron (2 pt.)

Ford GT (1 pt.)

Chevrolet C6 Z06 - 3pts
Ferrari F430 - 2pts
Mitsubishi EVO IX - 1pt

Chevrolet Corvette Z06 - 3 Points
Saleen S7 TT - 2 Points
BMW M5 - 1 Point


That was a tough decision, I wanted to put the F430 in there but I absolutely love the Z06 and the Saleen S7's are unbelievable cars. Can't go bitchin about a 500 hp sedan either, the M5's looks match it's performance almost perfect, not to mention you get the choice between 400 or 500 horsepower. The Bugatti is an awesome car but I think it's overkill, to me it's a car that resembles an attention whore. The Nissan/Infinit GT-R isn't a bad car either, I love the front and rear end but I HATE that roof, it needs to look more level or somethin, plus it's a 2007 car.

2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8 - 3 pts.
2006 Chevy Corvette Z06 - 2 pts.
2006 Pontiac Solstice – 1 pt.

The GC SRT8 is just an all around winner. First of all, Its a Jeep. Second of all, it's a 6.1 SRT Hemi V8. Third of all, its American. My reasoning is that it outpaces a Cayenne Turbo from 0-60 and has a top speed of 155. And I'm sure thats limited, which the Cayenne is probably too. Its fast as hell, and its a Jeep. Its got the power that only America could make. It really is the ultimate performance vehicle, on road and off.

The Chevy Corvette Z06 is an obvious contender because for like $60K or $70K, you get Ferrari 430 performance. And again, it's American.

And last but not least, the Pontiac Solstice. It's Miata matching performance with American flair. And the $20K price tag, its a winner in everyones book. And the soon-to-be turbo version just sweetens the deal. And i'm just fanticising here, but a coupe version fitted with a V8 (which can fit in the Solstice now) would be just awesome. And the perfect name would be "Equinox". But Chevy took it for a boring cute ute...

Those are my nominations.

2005 Mitsu Evo VIII - 3 Pts.
2005 BMW M3 - 2 pts.
2005 WRX STi - 1 pt

1st. Zonda F(has 7.3 AMG V12) (3PT)
You guys should listen to the video of Zonda's engine. Sounds like music to me!

2nd. Mercedes McLaren SLR (2PT)
Pure Grand Touring with the ability to perform like a race car.

3rd. E55AMG(2003-up) (1PT)
Has monstrous torque, very comfortable, easy to modify, can smoke E60 M5 anytime at the quarter mile.

1. Chevrolet Corvette Z06
2. Pontiac Solstice
3. Chevrolet Cobalt SS

1. BMW M5-3 pts.

raised the bar at which an entire class of cars is at

2. Chrysler 300C SRT8-2 pts.

speed(425hp), style, 4 doors, cheaper than a bentley(only 40k)

3. Nismo Skyline Z-Tune-1 pt.

10.1 in the quarter mile. faster on the track than at the strip. reliable as any GTR. factory warranty. so complete of a car, NOTHING has been left untouched.
hey if bugatti veyron is eligible, then this HAS to be.

Ford GT - 3pts
Ford Mustang GT - 2pts
Ford F-250 Powerstroke TD KR - 1pts

1) Ford GT is one of the hottest things out, and keeps up with lambos, ferraries, and porshe. What more could you ask for half the price?

2) Mustang GT is also, alot to handle for under or right at 30K, easily customized and makes a huge apperance.

3) F-250 Powerstroke turbo diesel, king ranch, can pull anything, go anywhere, and look good doing it. Simple as it gets, F-250 is a common mans work horse.

2006 civic si -3 points

excellent style, lots of power specially for alittle car, and impressive handling. a 10 in my book

2005 mitsubishi evo VIII-2 points

great style, great deal, and impressive motor

2006 subaru WRX STI-1 point

wow and i mean wow on the new look, look at that engine no space under that hood(thats why it got last, no place for mods), and as expected by the sti's great handling

2005 mitsubishi evo VIII-2 points

great style, great deal, and impressive motor




just to make sure, do you want to select the 8th model over the newer 9th that came out in 2005?

1st.Chevy Corvette z06
2nd. Porsche carrera GT
3rd. Dodge Neon Srt-4

The vette because i personally think its the Best Vette ever made to date and will be hard to top

the Porsche I like because the sleek and sexy body styling

the Srt-4...........no comment

1. Ferrari 430 (3 pts)

Did u read about the car? yeah…go ahead... tell me its not iniquitous!

2. Mercedes McLaren SLR (2 pts)

SEXY... fast ... SEXY ... fast... SEXY … fast … SEXY… fast

3. Mitsubishi Evo. 9 (1 pts)

If my Grad school dzn't pay off and #1 & #2 are not with in my reach, i can have the fun of both with an affordable package!


ps: waiting on the NISSAN GTR verdict, and if its going to be a T model here in the US, if so, i might get that, but for now... its the EVO.

1. 2005 Bmw M3
2. 2005 Bmw M5
3. 2004 Ford Mustang Cobra SVT

Corvette Z06
Porsche Carrera GT
Pontiac GTO

1. 2005 SALEEN S7 (Usa) -3000 pts "look kills"
2. 2006 FERRARI F430 (Ita.) -2000 pts "its a ferrari"
3. 2005 LAMBO GALARDO (Ita.) -1000pts "authentic"

seen 'em all in auto show this dec 05, aaand never, @ least for my own passionated opinion, that these autos can ever compete with "the Cizetta V16" .... but oh wait...veyron is 1001 HP... that filthy ma'

1- BMW M5
2- Subaru Impreza WRX STI
3- Chevrolet Impala LS

The M5 is just, whoa. Impreza is an amazing car to drive. And the impala is in my opinion the best all around car to get. The m5 definitly wins car of the year hands down tho.

1. PORSCHE CARRERA S 997
The new CS is sexiest machine ever. Plus I also really like that porsche ditched the boxter lights, and made the 997 more traditional. It also performs very well. Next year #1 will be the cayman S.
2. CHEVROLET CORVETTE ZO6
Because a rear mounted tranny is a BIG plus in a FR sports car.
3. BMW M5
Yes is performs well, but no manual tranny? What has BMW gone to. I know that 7spd tiptronic is nice and all, but I think all car enthusiasts would love to see an old school 6 or 7 spd tranny.

1. PORSCHE CARRERA S 997
The new CS is sexiest machine ever. Plus I also really like that porsche ditched the boxter lights, and made the 997 more traditional. It also performs very well. Next year #1 will be the cayman S.
2. CHEVROLET CORVETTE ZO6
Because a rear mounted tranny is a BIG plus in a FR sports car.
3. BMW M5
Yes is performs well, but no manual tranny? What has BMW gone to. I know that 7spd tiptronic is nice and all, but I think all car enthusiasts would love to see an old school 6 or 7 spd tranny.

I hate to call you on this, but the M5 will have a 6sp manual in the US in late 2006. The transmission in it right now however is not tiptronic, its a sequential transmission. There is a huge difference between the two.

1st Place - Nissan Micra K12 series 160SR (Street racer)
2nd place - Seat Leon Cupra R, 20V TURBO
3RD PLACE - Honda Civic type R

Mr Jay

I hate to call you on this, but the M5 will have a 6sp manual in the US in late 2006. The transmission in it right now however is not tiptronic, its a sequential transmission. There is a huge difference between the two.


Nice, its good to see that the M5 will be offered with a manual, sequantials are all fancy and nice and i prefer them over any automatic, however for pure driving enjoyment the clutch/stick combo rules supreme.

1. BMW M5 (E60) - 3pts
2. Pagani Zonda F - 2pts
3. Ferrari F430 - 1 pt

The new M5 is the daddy of all supersaloons. 500bhp, 200mph. Nuff said.
The Zonda F improves on the already stunning C12S and is a staggering achievement for such a new car manufacturer.
Finally, while im not a huge fan of its looks, the F430 is simply an animal and deserves a place in the top 3.

Couldn't agree more, chief !!!

1.Corvette Z06
2.Ferrari F430 Modena (6speed gated of course)
3.Acura RSXtypeS

corvette from hell!!! need i say more?

Ferrari-True enthusiast's car

RSX tS best bang for the buck in my book

1. Mazda RX-8 3 Pts.

2. Chevrolet Corvette Z06 2 Pts.

3. Buggati Veyron 1 Pt.

We have to fight to save the rotary, the RX-8 is the last hope! The 'Vette is amazing. Outperforms everything underneath 120K for 70,000. The Veyron with it's governed 258 mph and 1001 horsepower (989 in the states) is an amazing car.

2005 Nissan NISMO Skyline GT-R Z-tune 3 pts
2005 Bugatti Veryon 2 points
2005 Subaru WRX Imprezza STI/ESX 1 pts

Dodge Viper SRT-10 (3pts)
Fast, good looks, amazing power,500hp dont know what the big fuss about the vette is its just another vette :disappoin
Dodge Charger SRT-8(2pts)
Very nice, good price,425hp and good looks, still debating those extra doors tho.
Dodge Ram SRT-10 (1pts)
Fastest production pick-up 500hp :naughty:
what can i say, I LOVE MOPAR

1) Chevrolet Corvette Z06 - 3 pts
2) Chevrolet Traillblazer SS - 2 pts
3) Pontiac Grand Prix GXP - 1pt

Love American cars (especially those with a chevy small block v8) - always have and always will!

All three of these cars are relatively affordable in their categories and performance wise are at the top.

I LOVE MOPAR


That's quite noticeable...however...until they get off their asses I'll only be fairly impressed, they know the capabilites of the Viper and until they realize the potential in it and make it faster/more powerful/LIGHTER I'll take the Z06. The Viper was, and still is a HUGE and bold statement car, it represents what all muscle car fanatics love, big cubic inches in a hell of a car, but Chevy has caught up with their Corvette, with that 7.0 litre small block, granted I don't consider it an exotic, and it's not a supercar, although it can beat most of them in performance, it still needs something more to set it apart from the base Corvette, to the plain jane person they won't see the difference when it flys by, yet most of us here could spot the difference 100 yards away. The only thing the Viper has on the Vette now is it's exclusiveness(sp) and rareness. Do those mean the same? It does look world's better than the Corvette I think but c'mon. It's as if the Viper is the fullback and the Vette the running back of America, more nimble, while the fullback has more muscle and that in your face ass-kicking attitude. This probably isn't the forum to say this but I had to get a rant off. I'm a Chevy man for life but I feel let down by Dodge for what the Viper came to be, and now it's this, I know Dodge can do better, it just seems as if they don't care for the Viper anymore. I just wish they could list a 3.55 axle option, I mean 5th gear is designed to top out at 220, and you still have sixth gear to go, c'mon, there's where the Corvette can beat it in acceleration tests.

2005 gto
zo6 vette
2006 mustang cobra-i have seen one in person, long story
2006 grand caravan


Mod edit: Disqualified

2005 gto
zo6 vette
2006 mustang cobra-i have seen one in person, long story
2006 grand caravan
Do you have something against reading?

You will choose 3 cars and rate them

From now on we will not count nominations from anyone who hasnt followed the (simple!) instructions. We're not asking very much of you guys...

3 cars, clearly identified (make & model).

My accent #1 lol