96 c1500 A/T TIRES

I have a 96 c1500 I am at the point I have to start looking for tires. I will prob go back with an A/T I live on a dirt road and S GA mud you need all the help you can get, but I also want them to last and be safe in rain and normal driving. And I want to do this on the cheap. I currently have Kumo's which I guess Ive been pleased with but looking for recommendations. Also I think last time I went a size taller and wider and wondering if anyone has recommendations for tire sizes also looking for mileage but more intersested in getting home safely.

BF goodridge all terrains, continental sportivas, or goodyear wrangler silent armours-- same size as originally on your truck!