10,000+rpm
Pavlo
10-21-2004, 06:06 PM
This may sound kind of dumb but how to make to 10000RPM SAFELY on a sr20det, ka24de-t, I like revving the sh1t out of engines which is stupid but ohh well. :). I also know that it is bad for the engine, i usually go to 8500-9000 on friends 200sx se-r so does he, FUN lol.
Anyways so far i know that for sr you need to have rocker arm stoppers including with all the head upgrades. Can somebody tell what those upgrades should be on ka24de-t and sr20det s13.
Anyways so far i know that for sr you need to have rocker arm stoppers including with all the head upgrades. Can somebody tell what those upgrades should be on ka24de-t and sr20det s13.
rpgmage_86
10-21-2004, 08:38 PM
I'm pretty sure I've heard of a project drag skyline that has 13000 rpms. If that isn't street-bikish, I dunno what is.
Pavlo
10-21-2004, 08:40 PM
Actually i prolly will stay with ka and invet all the money on greddy turbo (450hp capable gives 205rwh when installed). It is actually faster then sr20det, so it is more efficient to keep the ka and upgrade it. I ll just do A LOT of head work to make it be able to rev like crazy.
R.W.240
10-21-2004, 10:45 PM
a 10,000 RPM Turbo KA. yeah you have fun with that.
assuming you build the bottom end... possibly 8,000? after that the Piston speed is gonna be high enough to rival an F1 car.
10k on an RB... possible
10K on a SR(T)... Iffy
10k on a KA(T)... Never. possibly if it was destroked. but who knows what would happen to the valvetrain above 9 (SRs have hoes above 9K too.)
assuming you build the bottom end... possibly 8,000? after that the Piston speed is gonna be high enough to rival an F1 car.
10k on an RB... possible
10K on a SR(T)... Iffy
10k on a KA(T)... Never. possibly if it was destroked. but who knows what would happen to the valvetrain above 9 (SRs have hoes above 9K too.)
publicenemy137
10-21-2004, 11:29 PM
If you want a rev monster, get a CA18. 8.5k redline stock
dustrman03
10-21-2004, 11:34 PM
wow. 10k aye. i would love 7500.
TatII
10-22-2004, 01:23 AM
the reason why a GT-R can rev to 10 +K is becusae the dimensions of the bore and stroke. all RB's are seriously over squared. the KA is waaay under squared. WARIO's GT-R has a 15K redline potential putting down 1300 awhp. but hes only reving it to 13K for more reliabililty.
Dreamspawn
10-22-2004, 06:50 AM
"assuming you build the bottom end... possibly 8,000? after that the Piston speed is gonna be high enough to rival an F1 car."
No offense but how long has it been since u watched F1? last time i checked idle was around 9,000rpm max was 17,500-19,000 depending on course and engine manfacture.
No offense but how long has it been since u watched F1? last time i checked idle was around 9,000rpm max was 17,500-19,000 depending on course and engine manfacture.
TatII
10-22-2004, 08:59 AM
a longer stroke engine will have a higher piston speed then a shorter stroke engine at a higher rpm.
example: a KA at 6000 rpm will probrably have a higher piston speed then a SR at 7500 rpm. since the piston has more distance to travel per stroke to complete one rpm. it has to move faster in one minute compared to a engine w/ith a much shorter stroke distance.
example: a KA at 6000 rpm will probrably have a higher piston speed then a SR at 7500 rpm. since the piston has more distance to travel per stroke to complete one rpm. it has to move faster in one minute compared to a engine w/ith a much shorter stroke distance.
musicsurfman
10-22-2004, 09:03 AM
You Can Make The Ka Rev Out Higher Maybe Not 10k But Alot Higher With Money.
Here Is A List Of Thing To Do:
Itb's Or Short Ram Intake Manifold (too Maintain Power)
Solid Lifter Cams And Nitrided Valves (for Strength And To Prevent Float)
Longer Rods For The Stock Stroke Or Destroke It
Overbore The Pistons As Big As It Can Go
Lighten All The Engine Internals And Rotating Mass.
Knife Edge The Crank To Reduce Oil Sump Drag
Raise Oil Pressure And Flow
Raise Water Pressure And Flow
Run High Octane Gas Or Alcohol
Build An Ignition System To Operate To Said Limit
Program A Standalone To Manage Engine Operations To Said Range
Dyno And Crossfingers!
10k Rpm Ka Is Possible But Would Be Very Expensive.
Ohh And Comparisons To A 2 Million Dollar F1 Engine Is Not Needed..... Any V8 With Only 3l And Half The Stroke Of Most Rbs, Twice The Size Of The Pistons, A 100 Times More Efficient Valvetrain, Head, Manifold, And Basically Everything Else Shouldn't Be Referenced Unless The Same Budget Is Applicable.
Here Is A List Of Thing To Do:
Itb's Or Short Ram Intake Manifold (too Maintain Power)
Solid Lifter Cams And Nitrided Valves (for Strength And To Prevent Float)
Longer Rods For The Stock Stroke Or Destroke It
Overbore The Pistons As Big As It Can Go
Lighten All The Engine Internals And Rotating Mass.
Knife Edge The Crank To Reduce Oil Sump Drag
Raise Oil Pressure And Flow
Raise Water Pressure And Flow
Run High Octane Gas Or Alcohol
Build An Ignition System To Operate To Said Limit
Program A Standalone To Manage Engine Operations To Said Range
Dyno And Crossfingers!
10k Rpm Ka Is Possible But Would Be Very Expensive.
Ohh And Comparisons To A 2 Million Dollar F1 Engine Is Not Needed..... Any V8 With Only 3l And Half The Stroke Of Most Rbs, Twice The Size Of The Pistons, A 100 Times More Efficient Valvetrain, Head, Manifold, And Basically Everything Else Shouldn't Be Referenced Unless The Same Budget Is Applicable.
S13wanabe
10-22-2004, 12:32 PM
If you want to rev to 10,000 then get a Honda. !0,000 is easy and reliable with any b series motor. The rdline on my ls/vtec will be around 10,000 - 10,300 with just pistons, cams, valve springs, port and polish. The stock valvetrain can handle 10,000 rpm, but I am building a track car and reliability is an issue.
SHIFT_KA24DE
10-22-2004, 12:40 PM
10k!? holy crap... that would be nice to drive around wouldn't it? haha... good luck. tell us if you succeed... including costs of parts and labor... lolz.
SHO411
10-22-2004, 01:31 PM
Pavlo, unless you just like sitting at the light and revving the shit out of your engine, you need a good 8-9K RPM, that is very sufficient.
If you want ot be stubborn, musicsurf said it best. You could also change the internals and make it over square, not like the RB but somethin close, but remember, Higher Rpm usually requires smaller displacement, the dist the piston travels is reduced but the speed increases, and other stuff, the only problem, high RPM ends up giving you less Tq. You will have the ability to hit higher speeds, but the take off will not be the best. Go read revenge of the Nerds at "nissanperformancemag.com", the article is blue printing.
By the way, if you ever acquire a Ka to play with, I've got this friend who works at an engine rebuild shop, he is the one I am going to take my SHO engines too, they can give you pointers on what to do, it is a small shop, but it will be cheaper having them break it down, then if you need costly stuff done, you can send it off, they will not charge you out the ass.
If you want ot be stubborn, musicsurf said it best. You could also change the internals and make it over square, not like the RB but somethin close, but remember, Higher Rpm usually requires smaller displacement, the dist the piston travels is reduced but the speed increases, and other stuff, the only problem, high RPM ends up giving you less Tq. You will have the ability to hit higher speeds, but the take off will not be the best. Go read revenge of the Nerds at "nissanperformancemag.com", the article is blue printing.
By the way, if you ever acquire a Ka to play with, I've got this friend who works at an engine rebuild shop, he is the one I am going to take my SHO engines too, they can give you pointers on what to do, it is a small shop, but it will be cheaper having them break it down, then if you need costly stuff done, you can send it off, they will not charge you out the ass.
SHO411
10-22-2004, 01:34 PM
Check at pull-a-part there at Buford hwy, last I was there they had like 8 S13, but 4 had the motors still inside, they are cheap, 70 bucks you can't beat that.
Pavlo
10-22-2004, 03:39 PM
aight thanks
by the way do people transplant ca18det in s14? I know it fits but what about the wiring harness? Nees to sepnd another hour on google now.
by the way do people transplant ca18det in s14? I know it fits but what about the wiring harness? Nees to sepnd another hour on google now.
Bryants95240sx
10-22-2004, 06:50 PM
ca wiring is the same as the sr.
R.W.240
10-22-2004, 10:20 PM
No offense but how long has it been since u watched F1? last time i checked idle was around 9,000rpm max was 17,500-19,000 depending on course and engine manfacture.
The Honda S2000 has F1 piston speed and its stroke doesnt suck.
Imagine what a (100?)mm stroke would be moving at at 9K
F1 piston speed isnt really all that special now-in-days the F20 at 9000, QR25 at 6800RPM, and the 13B all have piston speeds that rival F1 cars.
Piston acceleration on the other hand...
The Honda S2000 has F1 piston speed and its stroke doesnt suck.
Imagine what a (100?)mm stroke would be moving at at 9K
F1 piston speed isnt really all that special now-in-days the F20 at 9000, QR25 at 6800RPM, and the 13B all have piston speeds that rival F1 cars.
Piston acceleration on the other hand...
jmrev
10-22-2004, 10:25 PM
ive never heard of a sr20 or a ka24 @ 10k rpms, maybe if the car has a shorter displacement.
AWDSR20
10-23-2004, 02:17 AM
sr20det, 6500 more then enough. i dont even pass that. 10000rpm is not that usefull on a N/A mp motor i think.
Pavlo
10-23-2004, 11:41 AM
well it is not going to be na, not a big fan of that, force induction is the way to go ( i think) I will prolly pimp out the ka. For the 2000 i ll spend on sr20 ill just build the motor and do upgrades to the head.
musicsurfman
10-24-2004, 07:52 PM
when did 13b's get pistons? There are a few 10k rpm srs search the net there is a hks sr20det that can do over 11k rpms.
There are tons of high rpm NA motors... CART, INDY, F1 they all used to have non-FI engines. EVER heard of a motorcycle? Almost 200hp with over 13k rpms on tap NA.... Or the 1/2 Million dollar superbikes with over 280hp with 14-15k rpm redlines. With a better HP/Liter ratio than most race cars.
There are tons of high rpm NA motors... CART, INDY, F1 they all used to have non-FI engines. EVER heard of a motorcycle? Almost 200hp with over 13k rpms on tap NA.... Or the 1/2 Million dollar superbikes with over 280hp with 14-15k rpm redlines. With a better HP/Liter ratio than most race cars.
klohiq
10-25-2004, 08:10 AM
The Honda S2000 has F1 piston speed and its stroke doesnt suck.
Imagine what a (100?)mm stroke would be moving at at 9K
F1 piston speed isnt really all that special now-in-days the F20 at 9000, QR25 at 6800RPM, and the 13B all have piston speeds that rival F1 cars.
Piston acceleration on the other hand...
From what I've read the QR25 has the highest bore to stroke ratio out of any production street car. And the QR25 redlines at 6200...rev limited and JWT hasn't broken the ECU to raise it yet with a chip...though you can use an older sentra ecu, but that just brings a bunch of different issues. 6800-7200 is the absolute maximum you want to bring the car to with stock internals...even with upgraded internals it's a crap shoot whether it will survive for long.
Gotta love how low the torque comes on though...with the stock setup + mmi you can get rubber in third with 17x7 sport tires...top speed of 140 which is only drag limited...rev-limited to about 164...and it's very smoothe at 130+...
Imagine what a (100?)mm stroke would be moving at at 9K
F1 piston speed isnt really all that special now-in-days the F20 at 9000, QR25 at 6800RPM, and the 13B all have piston speeds that rival F1 cars.
Piston acceleration on the other hand...
From what I've read the QR25 has the highest bore to stroke ratio out of any production street car. And the QR25 redlines at 6200...rev limited and JWT hasn't broken the ECU to raise it yet with a chip...though you can use an older sentra ecu, but that just brings a bunch of different issues. 6800-7200 is the absolute maximum you want to bring the car to with stock internals...even with upgraded internals it's a crap shoot whether it will survive for long.
Gotta love how low the torque comes on though...with the stock setup + mmi you can get rubber in third with 17x7 sport tires...top speed of 140 which is only drag limited...rev-limited to about 164...and it's very smoothe at 130+...
revjunkie81
03-07-2009, 07:05 AM
If you want to rev a relatively standard motor with mild modifications then buy a honda motor or a rotary. If you want to rev to 15,000 + rpm then buy any motor that can flow that volume of air and build it to be able to do those sort of revs.. remember to consider the motor you choose in the beginning and to check that its enginereering charecteristics represent properties such as better valve angles etc before you upgrade to 3rd party components. (you will then get better bang for buck).. ps to the noob that posted "when did rotorys get pistons?"... well in case you havent noticed a rotory is an internal combustion engine and it has a rotor, which is a piston. anyway cheers.
nissanfanatic
03-14-2009, 08:43 PM
This thread is four and a half years old.
Automotive Network, Inc., Copyright ©2025